I'm sure that I'm wrong, but I'm starting to have a crazy feeling that Katy may have spoken at my college around 2000 or 2001, during her Katy Hudson days. I was involved with a Christian fellowship, and I vaugely remember a Christian singer who looked like Katy speaking (and maybe singing) at an event, and she may have been selling her album. There is something vaguely familiar about Trust in Me, although I've only heard it on YouTube. Again, I'm sure I'm wrong, and it's probably another Christian singer who looked like Katy.
Also, did her sister ever live in Rhode Island? Again, I'm sure that I'm wrong, but I do remember a speaker at that Christian fellowship being accompanied by an older sister, and I remember talking with the sister after the event!! Again, I'm sure that I'm wrong, but I'm starting to have this strange feeling that it was Katy and her sister that I met back in 2000 or 2001.
SmackUTwice, you must know the answer to this